Sunday, 15 July 2012

Lexus, Infiniti and Acura

Many of us today know of Japanese luxury car brands such as Lexus, Infiniti and Acura. These 3 luxury brands were created by Toyota, Nissan and Honda respectively in the attempt to move their cars further up the luxury chain in the US. Toyota did a good job marketing Lexus in the US making it the top luxury brand in the US for more than 10 years straight. Nissan and Honda followed a few years later with their Infiniti and Acura brands with decent success.

The question I always wonder is whether the extra sticker price really justifiable. In Japan the Lexus brand was not introduced until 2005, it took the Japanese market some time to really accept the Lexus brand as a premium brand of cars. The Japanese public always viewed Toyota as just a ordinary car marque without the luxury tag. With the introduction of the Lexus brand Toyota took the extra step to create a luxurious image for themselves.

Toyota has always been regarded as a car manufacturer that produced reliable cars with solid residual value but did not create any luxury brand value to make their brand sought after. However, in the eyes of a avid motoring fan the Lexus brand is no doubt a luxury brand but it is also regarded as nothing more than a better built Toyota with more functions and features. This the same for Infiniti and Acura. A classic example is how a Toyota Celsior in Japan is actually the same as the Lexus LS430. The build quality is similar and the functions are also almost the same. Why would you want to pay more for a different badge?! Shouldn't the cars be better built in the first place?



This is similar for the Nissan Fuga in Japan is the same as the Infiniti M35 but with a different badge. I somehow cannot get over the fact that some people are willing to pay extra for the Infiniti badge!






Are these companies taking the consumers for a ride? Merely changing the badge on the car and hiking up the selling price does not sound like making the car a luxury car.

I firmly believe when selling a luxury car, the car ought to be developed from ground up rather than just a rebadging job. Toyota, Nissan and Acura can easily develop models for their Lexus, Infiniti and Acura that look completely different and also developed from the ground up which can then be firmly regarded as a true luxury model worthy of the luxury badge.

Motoring journalists (those with true honest opinions) have not given any glowing reviews for any models (apart from the Lexus LFA which is on a totally different league as most people cannot afford to buy one) from Lexus, Infiniti and Acura as they all know that these cars are ordinary models with a different badge.

Thursday, 5 July 2012

Mid model life cycle face lifts

These days it is very common to hear that a car company is face lifting a particular model mid way through the model life cycle. The usual model life cycle for Japanese model is about 5 years and for European models is 7 years. Usually mid way through the model life cycle approximate 3 years after the initial introduction of the model, the car will receive some sort of alteration.

The usual alterations are as follows:-
- cosmetic changes to the bumpers, head lights, tail lights
- tweaks in the ECU for more power (not all car companies do this)
- minor changes in the interior (maybe colour tone or upgrade in audio system)
- addition of Day Time Running LED lights (seems like everyone is copying Audi)
- change in wheel design
- upgrade of ECU program to eliminate earlier bugs
- alteration of traction control system (rarely happens)

The objective of having a mid model life cycle face lift is to freshen the look and remind the consumers that the car is now newer looking. The plan is to attract back the buyers to the showroom. Nearly all car companies just do cosmetic facelifts as this is much easier to do and it isn't expensive in terms of development cost.  Most car companies they have already planned their mid model life cycle when they launch the car, some will even have ready ECU program upgrades to increase performance just to make the face lifted model more exciting and interesting. Competition in the car market is very fierce and once the car model starts to look old and newer models are introduced by competitors, the car companies have to think ahead to capture back the sales.

A car is like any other product, it will start to look old or dated when something new is introduced. Keeping up with the competition is always a difficult task.

Peugeot 308 - first face lift

Peugeot 308 - second face lift

It is rare to see a car company face lift their car models twice but in the case of Peugeot, that just happened. Underneath the cosmetic changes the car model is still the same.

Another company that also did two face lifts during the model life cycle was Nissan (Tan chong in Malaysia) which did it for the old Nissan Sentra. This model was first introduced around year 2000 and has gone through more than 1 face lift. This same model is still current available for sale making it one of the longest running model on sale in Malaysia. The question why this model is still for sales after so many years is down to the distributor's aim to maximise their returns on assembly line capital investment. Doing multiple facelifts over a long production period could mean two things. 1. the model is very boring and old; 2. the  model is practically bug free since the model has been in production so long that any and every possible bug has been rectified.

Monday, 2 July 2012

Collaboration between Toyota and BMW

This new announced collaboration between Toyota and BMW is an interesting one but I see Toyota benefiting more than BMW.

Here are the reasons:
- Toyota will be able to get hold BMW's awesome turbo diesel technology
- Toyota will learn BMW's engine down sizing technology
- Toyota will learn BMW's suspension setup and chassis technology

Toyota currently does not have the best turbo diesel engine for passenger cars and this has an impact on their sales in Europe where more than 50% of new cars sold are turbo diesel. Acquiring this technology will enable Toyota to have better market penetration in Europe.

All these technology from BMW are currently at the forefront of automotive engineering. It is not that Toyota is unable to develop similar technology but by collaborating with BMW they can short cut the development time and learn from the industry leader of such technology.

BMW will benefit in some ways by collaborating with Toyota if not they wouldn't collaborate.
Here are some of the potential areas they can benefit:
- BMW can learn about Toyota's small car and compact engine technology
- gain better understanding of Toyota's hybrid technology

Ultimately the collaboration is aimed at lowering development cost of new engines and new technology.

In the previous case of BMW's collaboration with Peugeot, the one that benefited the most was Peugeot as the 1.6 Prince engine co-developed by both companies were used in more Peugeot models than BMW models. BMW only used it for the Mini and the 116i model while Peugeot used the same engine for their 308, 408, 508, 3008, 5008 and RCZ.

Redefining the sports car

Toyota has traditionally been known to be a conservative car maker being famous for making very safe but boring cars such as the Toyota Camry, Toyota Corolla Altis and rugged Hilux models. Toyota left a long gap between sports car models such the MRS which was not really considered a true sports cars as it did not have the real performance nor the handling that sports car enthusiasts were looking for.

After almost 10 years since the last Supra rolled off the production line, Toyota finally introduced the GT86 which created quite a stir in the motoring industry. This is especially so when most car makers were obsessed with power and speed. The average new sports car now comes with 300hp or more and is capable of 0-100km/h in under 5 seconds. Toyota went back to the roots of sports car dynamics and made a car that made everyone remember how a real sports car is suppose to be like. Light weight, nimble, good handling, and sufficient power to have fun with.

The new GT86 is all that with good handling, sufficient power and have the correct front engine rear drive layout to enable the drive to get the tail out to have some serious fun. This car plugs the gap between the Mazda MX-5 and more powerful sports cars. The Mazda MX-5 have gotten a bit too large and too heavy as its dimension kept growing with the introduction of each new model. For the GT 86 some might argue that the car needs more power since it only has 197hp which is relatively low for a sports car in this current era. However with a low body weight the 197hp is sufficient to have fun with. For those who want more power there are always tuning kits from Japan which have already emerged.

The GT86 also filled a void where there were no sports car model in the Toyota stable for the mass market. Their next sports car, well actually a super car was the Lexus LFA which is cost more than 10 times more than the GT86 and is out of reach for 90% of the population. Making an affordable and simple sports car makes good sense for a time like this where people still want to buy a sports car but do not want to shell out over US$50,000 for it.

In the Malaysian context, selling this car may be an uphill battle for Toyota as the pricing (after tax) is not in their favour. At RM243,000 (for the manual version), it is competing in the same league as the VW Scirocco 2.0 Turbo, VW Golf R, Renault Megane, Civic Type R, Subaru Impreza STi and of course a used Porsche Cayman S (2006 model). All these cars offer more power and torque. I believe the GT86 will be reserved for a selected few who are true enthusiasts.

Monday, 25 June 2012

VW Passat 1.8T vs Toyota Camry 2.5

Toyota recently launched their 2012 edition Camry with the 2.0 litre and 2.5 litre engine models. this new model promises more refinement, better handling and better space. The new Camry is without a doubt a good car and Toyota has been improving this model for decades to bring it close to Lexus level.
The biggest threat to Toyota is now the VW Passat 1.8T rather than the traditional Honda Accord as the current Honda Accord model is getting old and is due to be replaced in 2013. Why is the VW Passat 1.8T a serious competitor to the Camry? The reason is simple. The cars are of similar size, similar price but both are engineered differently hence the interesting comparison.

Here is a direct head to head comparison:
Engine:
Toyota Camry 2.5: 181ps and 231Nm.
VW Passat 1.8T: 160ps and 250Nm

Transmission:
Toyota Camry 2.5: 6 speed automatic
VW Passat 1.8T: 7 Speed DSG

Vehicle Weight:
Toyota Camry 2.5: 1480kg
VW Passat 1.8T: 1517kg

Acceleration 0-100km/h:
Toyota Camry 2.5: 8.7 secs
VW Passat 1.8T: 8.5 secs

Fuel consumption:
Toyota Camry 2.5: 8.5 litres/100km (estimated)
VW Passat 1.8T: 7.0 litres/100km

With the statistics listed above it is very clear that engine downsizing works wonders for fuel economy and performance. The VW Passat is easily 20ps down on the Camry but the higher torque figures and better transmission efficiency pays dividends for the Passat despite the slightly heavier body weight.
VW has utilized the engine downsizing and ultra efficient DSG transmission to great effect to make the Passat a great contender for this segment of the market. Positioned as a mid size sedan, VW was able to bring the best of both worlds with good handling, solid highway stability, good fuel economy and ride comfort at a price cheaper than the new Camry 2.5.
In Malaysia VW offers 5 years warranty while Toyota offers 3 years warranty. The competition in this segment of the market just got hotter and Toyota has something to seriously worry about. The competition is no longer just with Honda Accord, Hyundai Sonata and the Nissan Teana. VW has joined the party with a strong contender and having a European badge with a similar price it may just swing many buyers over. For similar money, would you buy Japanese, Korean or German?

Thursday, 21 June 2012

BMW 520d vs Peugeot 508 2.2 Hdi

Not all car manufacturers are created equal and all have different levels of engineering. This is due to their history, philosophy and their approach to design and engineering.
Companies such as Toyota are very conservative and but they constantly introduce various new technologies as they go along. Their rate of technology introduction is not as fast as they strive for out right reliability before allowing the technology to be part of their new car. Then there are companies such as BMW are more dramatic and always introduce some new technology with every new model launched. This naturally puts them ahead of most of their competitors and make them look like serious innovators.
The major car manufacturers invest hundreds of millions of dollars in engineering and research and development every year to improve their cars. I shall discuss an example of the different levels of engineering for 2 different car companies with similar classed models.


BMW - F10 520d - this model is the entry level model for BMW's 5 series range. Putting out 184hp and 380Nm, this car promises refinement, good handling, comfortable ride and very good fuel economy. At present the 520d is one of the top selling 5 series model for BMW. It is able to accelerate from 0-100km/h in 8.1 seconds while consuming just 5.2 litres per 100km of diesel.


Peugeot 508 2.2 HDi - this is a flag ship model for Peugeot with good interior space, decent ride and handling and good exterior looks. The performance of this car is also good for a diesel engine with performance figures standing at 201hp and 450Nm. This car is able to accelerate from 01-00km/h in 8.2 seconds while consuming  5.7 litres per 100km of diesel.

These two cars are of similar size and weight but both car companies demonstrate the different levels of engineering. The BMW is still superior in engine and transmission technology as their 520d model is able to out perform the Peugeot in terms of acceleration and fuel economy. Overall the performance difference between the 2 cars is very close. It is not that the Peugeot is not good. It is just not as good as the BMW overall. One would argue that both cars are  in a different league because of price however price should not be a factor as these two cars are of similar size, weight and category. On paper the Peugeot has more power and torque but why is it not translated into real world performance? At a glance, one would expect the Peugeot to easily out perform the BMW as the Peugeot has 17hp and 70Nm advantage over the BMW. The difference is in the transmission system and how the power is put to the wheels. Having high performance engines is good but having a weak or inefficient transmission will really take the bite of the advantage from the engine.

Wednesday, 20 June 2012

Malaysia's National Automotive Policy

Every country has their own national automotive policy to cater for their own domestic market. Some of the policies are skewed towards Going Green to help the environment and some are designed to promote and protect local manufacturers, and some are there to help overall growth of the automotive industry domestically.
In Malaysia, the National Automotive Policy is more flawed than a pothole ridden road. The National Automotive Policy (NAP) has been designed specifically around the protection of Proton and Perodua, and to aid the well connected businessman who are within the close circle of government ministers with the seriously flawed Approved Permit (AP) system. This AP system was subject to abuse and made many government linked businessmen very rich by only selling import permits for US$15,000 each. To make matters worse, these businessmen where making it difficult for car distributors or even car manufacturers to import their own cars. This AP system was initially planned for abolishment in 2010 but until today this system is still being used as the government linked businessmen were able to lobby for further extensions. This has meant that imported car prices will remain one of the highest in the world. For the sake of enriching a few businessmen the country continue to suffer. Loss of jobs, loss of foreign investment and burdening the public with high priced cars.

Over the years the Malaysian government has changed their NAP to try to evolve with the times however it has always fallen short of anything significant and this has frustrated many car manufacturers. This has led to many of them opting to invest heavily in Thailand and Indonesia instead. The loss of foreign investment is well over US$200 million in direct capital investment and massive opportunity cost in terms of employment and local parts supply business. One foreign business report estimated 200,000 potential jobs would be created if the automotive industry was open. Foreign car manufacturers are constantly confused with the policies tabled in the NAP. Many don't know found that the policies were not fair and they simply did not have the confidence to invest in Malaysia.
Proton is a poorly managed car manufacturer that is like a baby that refuses to grow up. Surviving on government protection, Proton's days are numbered. As the Malaysian government has been under tremendous pressure from neighbouring countries and other trading partners to liberalize the automotive industry. As each NAP is tabled the Malaysia automotive industry is slowly opening up. It is still a positive step considering how slow it takes for any significant changes to be seen. The changes in Malaysia's NAP is still seen by many as a half baked attempt to pacify trading partners and foreign car manufacturers.
Having made Proton a private company again, the Malaysian Government may not necessarily protect Proton as much as before and this could spell some positive changes to the automotive industry. Whether this will happen is still questionable.

The current political scene in Malaysia is a hot debate as the Opposition party has garnered tremendous support. With the ruling party being the one behind the NAP and Proton, if the Opposition wins the next upcoming elections, there is a possibility for car lovers in Malaysia to rejoice as the NAP will be completely different and the AP system will most likely be scrapped with immediate effect. The NAP will probably see a much more open automotive industry to stimulate more foreign investment, creation of jobs and promote more local supply business opportunities.

As far as I know, all Malaysians would wish to have more affordable cars and not be saddled with crazy car loans stretching up to 9 years! Owning a car should not be a luxury but a right to a basic necessity.